FIRE INVESTIGATION IN COMMERCIAL KITCHEN EXHAUST SYSTEMS .... by Phil Ackland, of Phil Ackland and Associates, LLC and A. Elwood Willey, CFI , and Retired Senior Associate of FIREPRO Incorporated

Each year, thousands of fires occur in commercial kitchens. Because the details of many of these fires are complex the need arises for an investigator to have a clear understanding of the commercial kitchen environment (appliances, fire suppression systems, and exhaust systems).

This manual is a concerted effort to simplify many of the issues that surround the investigation of fires in commercial kitchens.

This peer reviewed manual is specifically written for fire investigators, analysts, engineers, special experts, and attorneys to provide them with detailed knowledge of kitchen exhaust and fire suppression systems and, to a limited degree, the performance of cooking appliances.

Every fire scene is different; this manual will give you a starting point to begin an investigation in a commercial kitchen.

CONTENTS OF THIS MANUAL

 

Chapter One: General Information
This chapter discusses the general information that all fire investigators should know. It outlines the incident data, the purpose of investigations, the methods, legal considerations, and expert testimony.


Chapter Two: Codes and Standards
This chapter reviews the major codes and standards used in the design and installation of commercial kitchen exhaust systems. It also covers code analyses concepts for investigations.

Chapter Three: Appliances
This chapter provides an overview of appliances and their applications and how the use of different appliances affect the amount of grease accumulation in exhaust systems. It also covers the ignition properties of cooking oils and fats.

Chapter Four: Kitchen Exhaust Systems
This chapter discusses the differences between Type I and Type II exhaust systems, and the theory of air movement. What the components of the exhaust system are; including different kinds of hoods, ducts, fans, and where the access panels should be located.

Chapter Five: Fire-Extinguishing Systems
This chapter addresses fire protection principles and requirements for commercial cooking appliances and exhaust system fire-extinguishing equipment.

Chapter Six: Non-Compliant
This chapter explains the different areas of non-compliance in the commercial exhaust system. Today non-compliant systems are created when contractors or installers ignore code requirements. These elements are factors in many of the more serious structural fires in commercial kitchens.

Chapter Seven: Conducting the Investigation
This chapter discusses how to plan the investigation, and how to organize both the investigation and the specialized personnel and technical consultants needed. It also discusses the fire scene examination and includes checklists for cooking appliances and equipment.

Chapter Eight: Interviewing
This chapter discusses what you should do while conducting interviews in the field. It includes sample questions to ask the restaurant management, incident witnesses, and system contractors.

Chapter Nine: Analysis and Reporting
This chapter will assist the investigator in the analysis phase of an investigation including origin and fire cause determination and determining the cause of the loss. A primer is provided on fire science and the use of time lines in fire analysis, selecting the final hypothesis (opinion), and report writing tips are included as well.

Chapter Ten: Case Studies
This chapter is a series of photos from seven case studies and actual field conditions illustrating deficiencies.

Chapter Eleven: Appendices


Peer Reviewers

The following individuals provided valuable peer review time and talent:

  • Besal, Barney, Technical Expert, Besal Services Inc., Atlanta, GA.
  • Bradbury, Steve, Technical Expert, Russell Food Equipment, Vancouver, BC, Canada.
  • Steve Coolidge, CRM, SFPE, Loss Control, CGI Insurance Services, AB, Canada.
  • Eddy, James R., CFI, Fire Chief Ret., Chief Fire Analyst, New England Fire Cause & Origin, Inc., Barrington, NH.
  • Foster, David L., Senior Technical Coordinator, Risk Decision Services, Insurance Services, Inc., Jersey City, NJ.
  • Hopson, Gary G., CSP, CFPS, ARM, Senior Consultant – Property Risk Control, Aon Risk Services, Southfield, MI.
  • Icove, David J., Ph.D., P.E., Adjunct Assistant Professor, University of Tennessee, Department of Electrical and Computer Engineering, Knoxville, TN.
  • Lentini, John, CFI, Fire Investigator, Applied Technical Services, Atlanta, GA.
  • Levin, Steven, Regional Risk Control Consultant, CNA Insurance, Downers Grove, IL.
  • McDonnell, Paul A. Attorney, Singleton Urquhart LLP, Vancouver, BC, Canada.
  • Neuens, Chad, Attorney, Neuens and Associates, St Paul/Travelers Insurance, Greenwood Village, CO.
  • Parikh, Jay, Code Consultant, Compliance Solutions International Inc, Chicago, IL.
  • Ray, Shaun, Director of Engineering, Metal-Fab Inc., Wichita, KS.
  • Roberts, Jim, Technical Expert, DPW Services, Louisville, KY.
  • Sauve, Stan, Fire Inspector, City of Calgary, AB, Canada.
  • Smith, Dennis W., Senior Fire Expert, Kodiak Fire & Safety Consulting, Fort Wayne, IN.
  • Stewart, Don, Senior Technical Expert, National Fire Services, Gurnee, IL.
  • Tracey, Sean, P.Eng. Canadian Regional Manager NFPA, Ottawa, ON, Canada.
  • Trellis, Javier, Ph.D., Senior Engineer, Hughes Associates, Baltimore, MD.
  • Wilson, Rory, Technical Expert, DPW Services, Louisville, KY.
  • Zawacki, George, Food Service Consultant, UpYourStack.com, Arlington Heights, IL.

Biography

A. Elwood Willey, CFI

For over 12 years, A. Elwood Willey, CFI, has served as a Senior Associate at FIREPRO Incorporated, where he manages the Fire Reconstruction Program.

He provides fire consulting and litigation support services to a variety of clients, including law firms, insurance companies, property owners, and product manufacturers. He conducts fire investigations and analyses of fire incidents including those involving commercial cooking equipment and exhaust systems.

Mr. Willey has over 35 years of fire safety experience, including 21 years with the National Fire Protection Association, where he was responsible for managing and reviewing major fire studies and conducting fire investigations. While at NFPA, he also served as a staff liaison to NFPA technical committees including the Committee responsible for NFPA 96. He is experienced in fire incident analysis, human behavior in fire projects, fire litigation support, and the fire service. Mr. Willey has authored over 25 professional articles, papers, and reports; and he has co-authored a chapter of the NFPA Fire Protection Handbook, 19th Edition. He is a member of the National Fire Protection Association's Committee on Fire Safety for Manufactured Housing and an alternate on the Committee on Venting systems for Cooking Appliances, holds a BS from the University of Maryland, and is a Certified Fire Investigator (IAAI).

 

RETURN TO TECH TOPICS BUY IT